• Skip to main content
  • Access
  • Authors at Current
  • Backdoor
  • Current
  • Log In
  • Login Customizer
  • Reviews
  • Search
  • Test
  • Thank you for subscribing
  • The Arena
    • About The Arena
  • Masthead
  • Your Profile

Evangelicals respond to the death of Jimmy Carter

  |  December 31, 2024

He was the first “born again” president and he was elected during Newsweek magazine’s “Year of the Evangelical.” So what are evangelicals saying about the recent death of Jimmy Carter?

Christianity Today is running an obituary by historian David Swartz. A taste:

In the end, Carter revealed the full dimensions of a diverse evangelical movement. For those convinced that conservative theology requires conservative politics, the former president showed that evangelicals sometimes take moderate and progressive views on civil rights, the environment, and gender equality. Carter’s political career also showed significant limits. This progressive evangelical may have reached the highest office in the nation, but he was left behind as backlash from his own people hamstrung his presidency and sabotaged a potential second term.

The tensions resulting from such high political visibility have largely resolved. The passage of time, the achievement of humanitarian triumphs, and the genial specter of an old man hammering nails and teaching Sunday school in rural Georgia granted Carter the blessing of a long farewell to a remarkable life.

Mike Pence:

President Jimmy Carter served America with distinction throughout his life and Karen and I extend our deepest sympathies to his family along with millions of Americans who admired this truly good and great man. From his service in the @USNavy, as Governor of Georgia and as the…

— Mike Pence (@Mike_Pence) December 29, 2024

Apparently Daniel Darling retweeted Pence’s post, leading to this interesting exchange:

Seriously @dandarling? “lived out his Christian faith with integrity and devotion”? There is no cause to be nasty with Carter’s passing but there’s also no need to lie. He promoted abortion and gay marriage as compatible with Christianity. And I think national review summarizes… pic.twitter.com/NC2z6YcF8L

— Megan Basham (@megbasham) December 30, 2024

No, they weren’t. It’s one thing to give a general, “he devoted his life to the service of his country.” That’s fine. It’s something else to say that he lived out his Christian faith with integrity. Do you think promoting abortion and gay marriage in the church is integrity?

— Megan Basham (@megbasham) December 30, 2024

Megan has more to say:

These people are mentally ill. https://t.co/gxjVBPwU8U

— Megan Basham (@megbasham) December 30, 2024

Is this a reference to Carter?:

“Many will say to Me on that day, ‘Lord, Lord, in Your name did we not prophesy, and in Your name cast out demons, and in Your name do many miracles?’ And then I will declare to them, ‘I never knew you; depart from Me, you who practice lawlessness.’”
Matthew 7:22-23

— Tom Buck (Five Point Buck) (@TomBuck) December 31, 2024

More from Southern Baptist preacher Tom Buck:

I’ve preached funerals where the deceased had claimed to be a Christian but much in his life cast serious doubt on that claim.

I chose to say all the good I could to honor the man’s life, but preached the Gospel without assigning the man to heaven or to hell.

It is possible to…

— Tom Buck (Five Point Buck) (@TomBuck) December 30, 2024

Russell Moore remembers praying with Jimmy Carter:

Jimmy Carter told me to stop worrying about Donald Trump.

When Carter invited me to meet with him in his Atlanta office, just a few weeks after the world-shocking 2016 U.S. presidential election, I assumed the topic would be Donald Trump. After all, I was a vocal evangelical-Christian critic of Trump, and now the religious right was gathering steam for revenge. Some Trump-supporting evangelicals wanted me to be fired or the religious organization I was working for at the time to be defunded. I was rattled by what a Trump presidency would mean for American democracy and, more important, for the witness of the Church after white evangelicals proved to be Trump’s most loyal base. Carter was unfazed.

What would Carter’s death be without a theobro take:

2/ Carter’s faith resonated with liberal ideals—service, humility, and social justice. His Christianity is what one of my old professors would call "BOMFOG"—Brotherhood of Man and Fatherhood of God. Of course, service, humility, seeking justice, and loving your neighbor can be…

— Andrew T. Walker (@andrewtwalk) December 31, 2024

4/ The difference? Carter’s faith comforted the cultural left. Carter's Christianity posed no threat to the regnant liberal order. Yes, his faith motivated many good things for which I will not criticize. But on the whole, Carter's form of Christianity would allow it to become…

— Andrew T. Walker (@andrewtwalk) December 31, 2024

6/ Let’s not selectively celebrate faith only when it fits a preferred narrative. If faith matters, it matters in full—whether it aligns with our politics or not.

The beauty of Christianity is that it is the one worldview that provides both comfort and confrontation, which is…

— Andrew T. Walker (@andrewtwalk) December 31, 2024

And a theobro response to a theobro:

If someone in our church affirmed abortion rights, gay marriage, and a neo-orthodox view of Scripture, they would be exhorted to repent or face excommunication.

In other words without repentance, we would have treated them as an unbeliever, just as God’s word commands us to do… https://t.co/Pxk6fQOqd2

— Denny Burk (@DennyBurk) December 31, 2024

The leader of the theobros:

“There are political arguments to be had and historical debates that will go on and on, but Christians understand that the final verdict—and the only verdict that really matters—is before the throne of God, where all of us will one day stand.”

Read more:https://t.co/h47VHb2ocu

— Albert Mohler (@albertmohler) December 30, 2024

“Carter revealed an inordinate confidence in how he personally felt and how he personally imagined Jesus—while rejecting the clear teachings of Scripture.”

From my article today @wngdotorg on the life and legacy of Jimmy Carter. https://t.co/h47VHb2ocu

— Albert Mohler (@albertmohler) December 30, 2024

The National Association of Evangelicals:

We are grateful to God for the life and service of President Jimmy Carter. He was a man of deep Christian convictions and sought not only to apply his faith in his personal and political life, but also to share that faith with all who would listen.https://t.co/ETtLSOgJpp

— National Association of Evangelicals (@NAEvangelicals) December 30, 2024

Jim Wallis:

Jimmy Carter never left the evangelicals, but they left him. https://t.co/U8Ocz7UXge

— Jim Wallis (@jimwallis) December 30, 2024

Shane Claiborne:

pic.twitter.com/O2R3vVxTqi

— Shane Claiborne (@ShaneClaiborne) December 31, 2024

President Jimmy Carter dies -Shane Claiborne pays tribute https://t.co/oic1Fja7y1 via @YouTube

— Shane Claiborne (@ShaneClaiborne) December 30, 2024

So grateful for the life and witness of Jimmy Carter. When I met him, the person introducing us said, “Here is a man that used the White House as a stepping stone to go on and do great things with his life.”

He is a gift… and we will miss him. But I know there is a party on the… pic.twitter.com/kgyTJxCfUl

— Shane Claiborne (@ShaneClaiborne) December 30, 2024

Franklin Graham:

Former President Jimmy Carter was once asked who influenced his spiritual life the most. His answer was @BillyGraham.

Hear more about his friendship with Mr. Graham and his involvement with BGEA during his remarks at @TheBGLibrary dedication.https://t.co/xZavKR7Fnz

— BGEA (@BGEA) December 29, 2024

Former President Jimmy Carter died today at the age of 100 after more than a year in hospice care. He served as our nation’s 39th president during a turbulent time in the 70s and 80s when we were facing inflation and an oil shortage, and a hostage crisis in Iran. He and my father… pic.twitter.com/Q3aazo5eG9

— Franklin Graham (@Franklin_Graham) December 29, 2024

Jentezen Franklin:

Remembering the life and legacy of fellow Georgian and former President Jimmy Carter. My son Drake and I had the privilege of meeting him a few years back. Keep his family in your prayers this week. pic.twitter.com/mf62upoYtf

— Jentezen Franklin (@Jentezen) December 30, 2024

Greg Laurie:

President Jimmy Carter, Age 100, Passes Away

President Jimmy Carter, the oldest living president in history, passed away today at the age of 100 after spending two years in hospice care.

I had the unique privilege of meeting President Carter on three separate occasions, each leaving a lasting impression on me.

The first was at a Billy Graham Crusade in Atlanta, Georgia—a state where Jimmy Carter once served as Governor. Before the crusade began, Billy Graham was showing the President around when they came upon me. Billy introduced me, saying, “Mr. President, this is Greg Laurie. He is a preacher of the Gospel!” It was a profound honor to be introduced to President Carter in such a meaningful way.

The second encounter was on a commercial flight. I vividly remember the former president walking down the aisle, shaking hands with every single passenger, and humbly saying, “Hello, I’m Jimmy Carter.” That moment was unforgettable. Regardless of how one may have voted, it was an honor for everyone on that flight to shake the hand of a former president.

The third time I saw him was at the dedication of the Billy Graham Library, where we had our photograph taken together. Once again, President Carter was gracious and approachable, embodying humility and warmth.

In many ways, he may have been an even better former president than he was while in office. He dedicated much of his post-presidential life to serving others—teaching Sunday school at his church, working with Habitat for Humanity, and engaging in various humanitarian efforts.

We must have respect for the presidency and those who serve in it, even if we do not always agree with their policies. Today, I honor the memory of President Jimmy Carter, a man who exemplified service, humility, and faith throughout his remarkable life. Left to right, Franklin and Jane Graham, myself, George H.W. Bush and Barbara Bush, Cathe Laurie and Jimmy Carter.

President Jimmy Carter, Age 100, Passes Away

President Jimmy Carter, the oldest living president in history, passed away today at the age of 100 after spending two years in hospice care.

I had the unique privilege of meeting President Carter on three separate occasions, each… pic.twitter.com/WZ7bLnwGSc

— Greg Laurie (@greglaurie) December 29, 2024

Tony Perkins:

With the passing of former President Jimmy Carter, I encourage you to pause and think of the man as a person who spent his life serving his country and his fellow man. While there is much to disagree with on his politics and policies, he embodied what it means to serve others.…

— Tony Perkins (@tperkins) December 30, 2024

Gary Bauer:

Tom Rose and I look back at the Carter era.https://t.co/jIZ6IJ7k0Y

— Gary L Bauer (@GaryLBauer) December 31, 2024

Johnnie Moore:

This is also the legacy of President Carter (and there’s a much much longer list than this).

We owe future generations to not only celebrate what’s worth admiring about public figures but also what deserves critique.

In this we find the lessons of history, lest we repeat them. https://t.co/AUHDnF6HgE

— Rev. Johnnie Moore ن (@JohnnieM) December 31, 2024

Retweeted by Eric Metaxas:

Sincere tributes aside, Jimmy Carter’s legacy still hampers a world that Trump must now fix https://t.co/S6QbkvR5kX

— John Solomon (@jsolomonReports) December 31, 2024

More Metaxas:

You can disagree with someone's politics — as I vehemently did with Pres Carter's — and still be gracious in the hours immediately following his death. At least some of us aspire to that. There's still a place for civility and grace.

— Eric Metaxas (@ericmetaxas) December 29, 2024

“Meets his maker”:

What a tragedy.
One of the most failed presidencies in American history was under Jimmy Carter. Some of us still remember what it was like.

Pro-abortionist and globalist Jimmy Carter meets his Maker – as we all will someday. Just remember God‘s pro-life and the inventor of it.…

— Jack Hibbs (@RealJackHibbs) December 30, 2024

Samuel Rodriguez:

Rest in peace, President Jimmy Carter—a servant of God, a leader of men, and an example for us all. pic.twitter.com/HU42pDXlhv

— Samuel Rodriguez (@nhclc) December 30, 2024

Charlie Kirk:

Jimmy Carter represents a type of Democrat that no longer exists.

Christian, loving husband, and a true patriot.

He was objectively an awful president, but he loved America and never intentionally tried to do it harm.

America could use more Democrats like him.

— Charlie Kirk (@charliekirk11) December 30, 2024

Jimmy Carter was a failed president, but a decent man who tried his best to serve America throughout his long and distinguished life. He was a sincere Christian, and nobody could ever accuse him of simply trying to loot the country and cash in, like so many of today’s Washington…

— Charlie Kirk (@charliekirk11) December 29, 2024

Filed Under: Uncategorized