• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • Home
  • About
    • About Current
    • Masthead
  • Podcasts
  • Blogs
    • The Way of Improvement Leads Home
    • The Arena
  • Reviews
  • 🔎
  • Membership
  • Your Account
  • Log In
  • Member Assistance Request
  • Way of Improvement
  • About John
  • Vita
  • Books
  • Speaking
  • Media Requests

Bernard Bailyn: “Historians know how it all came out, but the people of the time didn’t”

John Fea   |  August 30, 2022 Leave a Comment

In this 2010 lecture, the late Harvard historian Bernardo Bailyn says:

Historians know how it all came out, but the people of the time didn’t. The most important things in their lives was the uncertainty. We haven’t got a clue about what’s going to happen in Iran. We don’t even know what’s going to happen next week…It is the uncertainty and the complications of their lives which historians know the outcome of…The consequence of this is that historians, to find out how it got to be the way it got trace the antecedents of that outcome, that’s what historians do for a living. They take the origins of the First World War, or whatever you’re studying,…and go back to the antecedents of it and they trace a line of events, and documents, and people, and decisions, and so forth and they can then explain to you why you had World War I. The problem with this is that it become inevitable. It’s an inevitability that’s built into the stories they tell because of this process. And that is what troubles me about historical study, and there’s no way to overcome this…except to recognize the contingencies, the uncertainties, all the accidents, that went into this–there’s no straight line development, it goes through all sorts of contortions that are wiped clean out when you simply take the outcome and trace the antecedents of it. That’s what troubles me with historical study, because it falsifies what happened.

Bailyn then uses the history of the United States Constitution as an example.

Watch:

RECOMMENDED READING

The Sights and Sounds of Belfast David Barton spreads blatant falsehoods about the AP US History course, state history standards, and a bunch of other stuff. Stranger Things: Not So Strange at All Default ThumbnailAsbury University revival roundup: February 20, 2023 at 11:58AM

Filed Under: Way of Improvement Tagged With: Bernard Bailyn, contingency, historical thinking, presentism

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Footer

Contact Forms

General Inquiries
Pitch Us
  • Manage Your Account
  • Member Assistance Request

Search

Subscribe via Email



Please wait...
Please enter all required fields Click to hide
Correct invalid entries Click to hide
Subscribe via Email


Please wait...
Please enter all required fields Click to hide
Correct invalid entries Click to hide