• Skip to main content
  • Access
  • Authors at Current
  • Backdoor
  • Current
  • Log In
  • Login Customizer
  • Reviews
  • Search
  • Test
  • Thank you for subscribing
  • The Arena
    • About The Arena
  • Masthead
  • Your Profile

What I love about James Sweet’s piece on presentism

  |  August 22, 2022

James Sweet, President of the American Historical Association

I wanted to get these tweets on record here at the blog. Also, some readers of the blog are not Twitter.

I’m not going to go into background, but I encourage you to get up to speed here.

Again, I write as a historian who has published six books, taught history for a quarter century at both the high school and college level, have worked with thousands of K-12 teachers through the Gilder-Lehrman Institute, authored a textbook on historical thinking, and currently serve as president of an AHA-affiliated historical association. In all of these capacities, I have written history books that directly address the present (and I am currently working on one now) and I have written books that do not.

As I see it, the attack on Sweet’s piece by those on the Left is no different than the attacks on the historical discipline from those on the Right (and the Christian Right). There is a reason why a 2012 History News Network survey of historians chose books by David Barton and Howard Zinn as “the least credible” history books in print.

Here are some tweets from this morning (and one from last night):

You don’t have to be a conservative to critique activist history:

Many of those appalled by Sweet’s piece should be reminded that these debates are not new to the profession. Back in the late '60s Eugene Genovese, a Marxist, was making the same case against so-called activist historians.https://t.co/H3pq04tmmg

— John Fea (@JohnFea1) August 22, 2022

Sweet's piece was a necessary reminder that @AHAhistorians includes historians who are not inclined to doing history that merely serves the present. Historians explore the past as both “a foreign country” & as “useful.” https://t.co/H3pq04tmmg

— John Fea (@JohnFea1) August 22, 2022

A lot of us are getting excited about teaching our methods classes this semester!

Working on my Intro to History syllabus right now. On week 3 I'll make the case for a useable past, & how history informs the present. On week 4 I'll argue in the same way James Sweet does in his @AHAhistorians piece. #whystudyhistory

— John Fea (@JohnFea1) August 22, 2022

I've been saying this more than a decade about the likes of @DavidBartonWB and the Christian Right view of history. Glad Sweet wrote this piece.

— John Fea (@JohnFea1) August 22, 2022

This is so good from Sweet's piece: "Doing history w/ integrity requires us to interpret elements of the past not through the optics of the present but within the worlds of our historical actors." And yes–ALL historical actors. https://t.co/FzW0GC3FoF #aha #presentism

— John Fea (@JohnFea1) August 22, 2022

Historical questions often emanate out of present concerns, but the past interrupts, challenges, and contradicts the present in unpredictable ways. Indeed, as Sam Wineburg argued, it is an "unnatural act." So good. https://t.co/FzW0GC3FoF

— John Fea (@JohnFea1) August 22, 2022

What strikes me about this whole debate over Sweet's @AHAhistorians piece is that everyone wants to be a historian. It's really not that sexy you know! If you want sexy, become a political activist who uses the past to advance your present-day agenda. You'll get more followers.

— John Fea (@JohnFea1) August 22, 2022

What strikes me about this whole debate over Sweet's @AHAhistorians piece is that everyone wants to be a historian. It's really not that sexy you know! If you want sexy, become a political activist who uses the past to advance your present-day agenda. You'll get more followers.

— John Fea (@JohnFea1) August 22, 2022
+ postsBio
  • https://currentpub.com/author/
    That’s a wrap!
  • https://currentpub.com/author/
    The Way of Improvement Leads Home blog has moved
  • https://currentpub.com/author/
    Pamela Paul’s last New York Times column
  • https://currentpub.com/author/
    Evangelicals and politics roundup: Wisconsin, Cory Booker, spiritual warfare, refugees, and more.

Filed Under: Uncategorized