• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Current
  • Home
  • About
    • About Current
    • Masthead
  • Podcasts
  • Blogs
    • The Way of Improvement Leads Home
    • The Arena
  • Reviews
  • 🔎
  • Way of Improvement

Is Democratic Socialism anti-Christian?

John Fea   |  April 14, 2021

Here is a taste of Stephen Mattson‘s piece at Sojourners: “Why Democratic Socialism Isn’t Anti-Christian“:

Contemporary Christians are among those who have embraced the democratic socialist platform as a necessary check against an economy and political system they view as corrupt, elitist, and oppressive. Scholar and activist Cornel West recently wrote on Facebook: “Democratic socialism comes in many forms, but it’s fundamentally the idea of being committed to the dignity of ordinary people.” The Institute for Christian Socialism, where West serves as an advisor, and its magazine, The Bias, have highlighted the growing number of Christians who are convinced that “the socialism of the Gospel is irreconcilable with capitalism” and seek “new forms of political economy.” For these Christians, capitalism is a selfish system of greed, fundamentally contradicting Christ’s commands to selflessly love your neighbors.

While the life of Jesus and the gospel message fail to explicitly endorse any specific party affiliation, contemporary Christians who embrace socialism note that scripture is full of appeals to sacrificially give, care, and provide for others, including Christians who practiced collective ownership. For example, Acts 2:44-45 states, “All who believed were together and had all things in common; they would sell their possessions and goods and distribute the proceeds to all, as any had need.” For Christians who embrace socialism, their faith in a community that seeks a way of selfless love has led them to critique the failures of capitalism and look for alternative systems.

Nevertheless, many white evangelicals maintain that socialism is a fundamentally anti-Christian political system. Rather than value the elements that promote fair wages, economic justice, and welfare services, they wholly interpret socialism as a secular system where religion is vilified and atheism is promoted. They leave no room for Christianity and socialism to co-exist, even though history is full of prominent Christians who’ve embraced aspects of socialism and/or critiqued aspects of capitalism, including Desmond Tutu, Mother Jones, Dom HĂ©lder Câmara, Wendell Berry, James Cone, and Dorothy Day, a radical Catholic who took seriously the instruction of the Catholic catechism to ensure wages “guarantee … a dignified livelihood”  so workers and their families can thrive at the “material, social, cultural, and spiritual level, taking into account the role and the productivity of each, the state of the business, and the common good.”

One of the dangers of pro-capitalist Christians — or Christians who champaion any particular economic system— is that their preferred  beliefs can become idols. Even the most “theoretically good” political and economic systems can be corrupted if they are run and managed by horrible people. Christians should know this better than anyone, as many prominent faith communities, churches, and Christian movements throughout history have promoted and participated in all sorts of evils.

Read the entire piece here. Nice work.

John Fea
+ postsBio
  • John Fea
    That’s a wrap!
  • John Fea
    The Way of Improvement Leads Home blog has moved
  • John Fea
    Pamela Paul’s last New York Times column
  • John Fea
    Evangelicals and politics roundup: Wisconsin, Cory Booker, spiritual warfare, refugees, and more.
  • John Fea
    Goodbye to a Four-Year Labor of Love
  • John Fea
    Wisconsin sends Trump-Musk a message
  • John Fea
    “Would you want your doctors not to be revisionists?”
  • John Fea
    All four #1 seeds made the Final Four this year. What happened to Cinderella?
  • John Fea
    It’s the last week of CURRENT
  • John Fea
    Sunday night odds and ends
  • John Fea
    Trump’s executive order on American history has little to do with history
  • John Fea
    Should Jeffrey Goldberg have “left the room?”
  • John Fea
    What an ending!
  • John Fea
    “You can’t hold onto anything in this world. That doesn’t mean you can’t squeeze it all so tightly to your heart that it hurts.”
  • John Fea
    Is Trump capitulation “on the way out?”
  • John Fea
    Did Patrick Henry really say “Give me liberty or give me death?”
  • John Fea
    Hey Silicon Valley, “Christianity…is not a religion that can reliably deliver socially desirable outcomes, nor is it intended to be.”
  • John Fea
    The second Trump presidency is two months old. What are evangelical saying?
  • John Fea
    We need more democrats
  • John Fea
    “What if the Mets are actually good now?”

Filed Under: Way of Improvement Tagged With: capitalism, Cornel West, democratic socialism, socialism