Last summer a group of K-8 history teachers urged me to write a popular biography of Philip Vickers Fithian. Here is what I wrote back then:
I am always amazed when I talk to people who develop strong emotional connections to the characters in The Way of Improvement Leads Home: Philip Vickers Fithian and the Rural Enlightenment in Early America. I did not expect the book to be a tearjerker. The title is long and technical. It is published by a university press. Most bookstores do not carry it. When my first royalty check arrived, I spent it all on Christmas presents. When the second royalty check arrived, I spent it all on a nice dinner for my family. Today I can still splurge for dinner with the annual check, assuming that the meal is eaten at Arby’s.
But since the book first appeared in 2008, a few dozen people have told me that they cried at the end. This week at the Princeton Seminar, five teachers mentioned that the final chapter brought them to tears.
— Ms. Kathy (@snoopie62) July 19, 2017
Philip Vickers Fithian’s story does have an emotional ending, but I am still surprised that a book about the Enlightenment in America resonates with readers in this way.
Last week several K-8 history teachers (and at least one school librarian) attending the Princeton Seminar strongly encouraged me to write a biography of Philip for the young adult nonfiction market. I am taking their advice seriously. I don’t know very much about this market, but I want to learn more. After listening to these teachers, and thinking about this a bit more myself, I think that teenagers might find Philip’s story interesting for what it teaches us about everyday life in colonial America, the early years of the American Revolution, love and courtship, education, self-improvement, and life on the frontier.
Stay tuned. And if you have any advice I would love to hear it.
I thought about this possible project again after I read Elizabeth Elliott’s AHA Today post: “Experiments in Writing History.” Here is a taste:
Laura Kamoie still receives periodic royalty statements for a book she published over a decade ago—an economic history of the early American Tayloe family, based on her PhD dissertation from the College of William and Mary. She knows that, to date, it has sold 773 copies, an ordinary showing for a first book that might be assigned in a university class once in a while. As for the next work she lists under the publications section of her CV? That one has sold over 350,000 copies.
The wildly successful America’s First Daughter (2016) is not an academic history but a work of historical fiction. Using “the exact same research process as I did for my dissertation,” Kamoie, along with co-author Stephanie Dray, wrote a novel from the point of view of Thomas Jefferson’s eldest daughter Patsy. Headlining the jam-packed AHA18 session “Historians Writing Historical Fiction,” Kamoie talked about the ways she finds writing academic history and writing historical fiction similar, arguing that “both attempt to link known facts and try to shape them into some kind of a narrative. Both make historical contributions, and both are meant to generate curiosity about the past.”
Read the entire piece here.